After spending a week using both the Samsung Galaxy S24 FE and Google Pixel 8a, I’ve got a solid perspective on what these two mid-range contenders bring to the table. While both devices have strengths, choosing one largely comes down to what you value most in a smartphone. Here’s what I learned.
Why the Samsung Galaxy S24 FE Stands Out
Display and Design
One of the Galaxy S24 FE’s biggest strengths is its display. The 6.7-inch 1080p panel is vibrant, sharp, and well-suited to media consumption, gaming, and day-to-day use. I was already a fan of the S23 FE display, but this one takes it up a notch. Samsung’s flexibility with screen settings also allows you to tweak saturation levels to your preference, giving you control over the look of your display.
Design-wise, the Galaxy S24 FE channels Samsung’s more premium models, which makes it feel closer to a flagship than the Pixel 8a. Its sturdy build and sleek aesthetic closely mirror the higher-end Galaxy S24+. If you’re after a premium look at a mid-range price, this device might check that box for you.
Performance and Gaming Prowess
Powered by the Exynos 2400e chipset, the Galaxy S24 FE performs smoothly across day-to-day tasks and is particularly effective when it comes to gaming. The device handles high-performance mobile games at top graphics settings with impressive frame rates, outperforming the Pixel 8a in this area.
Additionally, the Galaxy S24 FE has a vapor chamber cooling system that helps the device stay cooler during extended gaming sessions.
When it comes to software, Samsung has done a great job with updates, offering consistent support and reliability. The Galaxy S24 FE joins other Samsung devices in receiving an extended seven-year update policy for both software upgrades and security patches.
Galaxy AI Features
Samsung also incorporates Galaxy AI tools on the Galaxy S24 FE, like Sketch to Image and its version of Magic Editor. While functional and interesting, these features aren’t necessarily a reason to opt for this device over others. It’s nice to have them, but they don’t significantly impact daily usage.
Why the Google Pixel 8a Shines
Camera Capabilities and Photography
The Pixel A series has long been known for delivering impressive camera performance, and the Pixel 8a stays true to this legacy. Compared to the Galaxy S24 FE, the Pixel 8a delivers consistently great photos, especially in challenging lighting.
While the Galaxy S24 FE has a versatile camera setup, including a 3x optical zoom, Google’s computational photography delivers exceptional detail, contrast, and sharpness across a range of scenes. For point-and-shoot photography, the Pixel 8a is hard to beat.
Pure Android and AI Integration
Running Android 15 with Material You, the Pixel 8a provides a clean, customizable Android experience. It also benefits from Google’s seven-year software update policy, ensuring that users receive the latest features and security patches.
Google’s Pixel feature drops add fresh capabilities a few times each year, and Gemini Live—a feature that uses AI to enhance live wallpapers—adds a touch of personalization that is both functional and fun.
The Pixel 8a’s Tensor G3 chipset is not a powerhouse by flagship standards, but it delivers snappy performance across routine tasks and handles AI-related functions well.
When it comes to day-to-day use, the performance gap between the Pixel 8a and Galaxy S24 FE isn’t particularly noticeable, aside from high-end gaming.
Compact Form and Display Upgrade
The Pixel 8a’s compact 6.1-inch size and ergonomic design make it comfortable to hold, and for fans of smaller phones, this device delivers great one-handed usability.
The new Actua display on the Pixel 8a addresses the shortcomings of previous Pixel displays, offering improved brightness and vibrancy that make content look much better. While it’s not as large or as high-res as the S24 FE’s display, it’s a significant improvement over past models and is perfect for users who prefer smaller devices.
Pricing and Value
When it comes to price, both of these mid-range phones are excellent options—if you can find the right deals. Carrier offers, trade-ins, and holiday discounts make both devices more affordable.
If you can snag the Galaxy S24 FE for under $500, it’s a strong option that justifies the price with its high-end feel and gaming capabilities. Similarly, the Pixel 8a offers great value at under $450, especially for those focused on photography and a pure Android experience.
Final Takeaways
Both the Galaxy S24 FE and Pixel 8a bring compelling features to the mid-range smartphone category, but each one appeals to a slightly different audience.
If gaming, a larger display, and a premium design are top priorities, the Galaxy S24 FE is a solid choice. On the other hand, if you prioritize camera performance, software experience, and a compact design, the Pixel 8a stands out.
